Switch from Subsplash, Tithely,
or Pushpay. Without losing
a single member.
We handle the migration end-to-end. Giving history, sermons, members, push subscribers. Your congregation never notices the change.
3-4 week migration · Recurring giving keeps running · Zero member friction
Where are you switching from?
The Switch Guarantee
You don't pay us a dollar until your new app is live and your members are on it.
If we can't deliver a clean handoff (giving uninterrupted, members migrated, data intact), you walk away at no cost. We only bill once your ministry has officially switched.
How the switch works.
Four weeks. No service interruption. Parallel-running so nothing breaks.
Week 1
Audit & export
We pull every piece of your existing app: giving history, recurring donors, sermon media, member accounts, small groups, events, prayer requests, and push notification lists. Nothing gets left behind.
Week 2
Build & configure
Your custom app is built with your content already inside it. We configure giving with your existing processor so recurring tithes continue without interruption. App Store and Play Store listings prepared.
Week 3
Soft launch to leadership
Staff, deacons, elders, and early-access members install the new app. Full data is visible. We run parallel with the old platform so nothing breaks. You sign off before the congregation sees it.
Week 4
Switchover Sunday
New app goes live to the full congregation. We time it with a Sunday announcement so members download it while they're thinking about it. Old platform sunsets the same week. Done.
Everything ports over.
Nothing gets left behind. Your old platform has exports. We know where to look.
Giving history
Every past donation, recurring tithe, and donor record. Annual statements unaffected.
Recurring donors
Active recurring gifts continue on the same schedule. No re-authorization from members.
Sermon library
Audio, video, notes, and series metadata. Organized by speaker, date, and topic.
Member accounts
Names, emails, phone numbers, family groupings, and directory listings.
Small groups & events
Group rosters, event calendars, RSVPs, and volunteer sign-ups.
Push notification subscribers
Every device token transfers. No one loses access to alerts.
App Store listing
We handle the transition with Apple and Google. Your app keeps its name and reviews where possible.
Custom branding
Logo, colors, typography, and every pixel of your existing design, rebuilt better.
What's different depending on where you're leaving.
Every platform has quirks. We've seen them all.
Leaving Subsplash?
Template platform you rent. Annual contracts. Your data is locked in their platform.
The pain
Your app is a template shared with thousands of other churches. You can't export cleanly.
How we fix it
We rebuild as a 100% custom app. Your media, giving history, and member data ports over. You own your data, domain, and accounts.
Leaving Tithely?
Free giving + paid branded app. Great at giving, thin on engagement.
The pain
The app is a basic wrapper. No real community, sermons, or denomination-specific features.
How we fix it
Recurring giving keeps working through the switch. New app includes everything Tithely didn't: sermons, groups, prayer, events.
Leaving Pushpay?
Enterprise giving at $500-$2,000+/mo. Two-year contracts standard.
The pain
You're paying enterprise pricing for giving, then still cobbling together the app side with ChMS add-ons.
How we fix it
We replace the app layer with a custom build at $250/mo. Keep your existing giving processor or switch. Your call.
The cost of staying put.
For a mid-sized church over 3 years.
| Platform | Monthly | Setup | 3-year total | Data ownership |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Subsplash | $300-$500/mo | $1,500+ | $12,300-$19,500 | No |
| Tithely Pro | $119-$149/mo | $0 | $4,284-$5,364 | No |
| Pushpay | $500-$2,000/mo | Varies | $18,000-$72,000 | No |
| Rehost Faith | $250/mo | $0 | $9,000 | Yes |
Questions pastors ask before they switch.
If yours isn't here, the migration call covers it.
What happens to our recurring giving during the switch?
Recurring gifts continue uninterrupted. We configure the new app with your existing giving processor (Stripe, Tithe.ly, Subsplash Giving, etc.) so members never have to re-authorize. If you choose to change processors later, we handle that migration separately with zero member friction.
Do our members need to re-download the app?
Yes, once. We time the switchover with a Sunday announcement so members download the new app while they're thinking about it. On iOS and Android, it's a one-tap install from a link we provide. Most churches see 80%+ member adoption within two weeks of switchover.
Will we lose any historical data?
No. Giving history, sermon library, member records, group rosters, event history, and push notification subscribers all migrate. We keep a read-only export of the old platform's data for 12 months as a backup.
How do you handle the App Store transition?
Two options. (1) We transfer your existing App Store listing to your new Apple Developer account, which preserves your app name, icon placement, and reviews. (2) We publish a fresh listing with your church's name and migrate members. We'll recommend based on your current platform's terms.
What if we're locked into an annual contract?
We still start. We run your new Rehost app in parallel while you wait out the contract. No double-paying: you don't owe us anything until switchover Sunday. If your current vendor has early-termination fees, we'll review them with you before you cancel.
How long does the full migration take?
Most churches complete the switch in 3-4 weeks. Complex migrations (multi-campus, heavy integrations, 10,000+ members) can take 5-6 weeks. We commit to a timeline in writing before we start.
What's your switch guarantee?
You pay $0 until the new app is live and your members are on it. If we can't deliver a clean handoff, you walk away with no obligation. We only bill once your ministry has officially switched.
Can we keep our existing app URL and branding?
Yes. We match the visual identity pixel-for-pixel, or upgrade it if you want. Custom URLs, deep links, and QR codes in your existing printed materials keep working.